The Lighthouse FerryPrintable murder mystery case file · Tern Island, Maine · October 1979

Home / Printables / Murder Mystery Case Files / The Lighthouse Ferry
The Lighthouse Ferry: printable murder mystery case file coverFree
2–3 hours37 documents38 pages3 sealed envelopes

A lighthouse keeper is found dead at the foot of his stair and the county calls it an accident. The box holds every surviving document: logbooks, tide tables, statements and the ferry schedule. Nothing is highlighted and nothing is in order.

  • Two editions: full colour and printer-friendly
  • Language: English
  • Nothing is shipped. One-time payment, not a subscription.

This one is free. No account, no email.

Also available in: Deutsch · Français · Español · Italiano · Nederlands · 日本語 · 한국어

At a glance

Playing time
2–3 hours
Format
PDF, 38 pages, full colour and printer-friendly editions
What is inside
37 documents, 3 sealed envelopes, solution in Envelope C
Language
English

What is in the PDF

37 documents from a 1979 Maine State Police file: the keeper’s log, Coast Guard radio records, tide tables, the ferry schedule, a boatyard fuel ledger, scene photographs, an island map and statements from six people who knew Silas Wren. Two sealed envelopes add the evidence a second look turned up, and the third holds the solution.

How printing and setup work: see How to play. Other questions: see our FAQ.

Good for

Game night with friends, couples who like true-crime puzzles, a rainy weekend alone with coffee.

The Lighthouse Ferry scene: the lighthouse lamp roomThe Lighthouse Ferry scene: the island and its lighthouse seen from the shoreThe Lighthouse Ferry scene: the spiral stair inside the lighthouse

Persons of interest

Five people who knew Silas Wren, as they appear in the case file.

Portrait of Nora Wren, a person of interest in The Lighthouse Ferry
Nora WrenThe victim's wife, 51. Runs the island post office counter.
Portrait of Dale Brody, a person of interest in The Lighthouse Ferry
Dale BrodyDeckhand on the Mary Ellen, 34. Also fishes his own lobster traps.
Portrait of Ingrid Sorensen, a person of interest in The Lighthouse Ferry
Ingrid SorensenVisitor renting Gull Cottage, 29. Says she is a painter.
Portrait of Everett Lusk, a person of interest in The Lighthouse Ferry
Everett LuskBoston property developer, 45. Wanted to buy Tern Point.
Portrait of Tom Wren, a person of interest in The Lighthouse Ferry
Tom WrenThe victim's son, 26. Lives on the mainland in Port Wescott.

Inside the case file

Printed pages from the file, ready to spread across the table.

Three printed pages of The Lighthouse Ferry case file on a wooden table: the cover, How to Work This File and Persons of Interest

About this case

The Lighthouse Ferry is a cold case set on Tern Island, Maine, in October 1979. A lighthouse keeper, Silas Wren, is found dead at the foot of his stair, and the county calls it an accident. The box holds every surviving document, with nothing highlighted and nothing in order. The scene photos show the lamp room, the island and its lighthouse seen from the shore and the spiral stair inside.

The 37 documents come from a Maine State Police file: the keeper's log, Coast Guard radio records, tide tables, the ferry schedule, a boatyard fuel ledger, scene photographs, an island map and statements from six people who knew the keeper. Two sealed envelopes add the evidence a second look turned up, and the third holds the solution.

The deck of a small ferry in the fog, heading toward an island lighthouse

It takes 2 to 3 hours and suits a game night with friends, a couple who like true-crime puzzles or a rainy weekend alone. The 38-page PDF comes in a full colour and a printer-friendly edition.

Among our case files, it is the island case, built around a lighthouse, the sea and the ferry. Dead Signal is a digital case in 2016 Chicago, The Last Encore a jazz club in 1994 New Orleans, Last Reel at the Orpheum a 1975 movie palace and Unlisted a 2020 Phoenix guest house.

Frequently asked questions

How many players is it for?

Any group size works. You can solve it alone, as a couple or with a big group.

How long does it take?

Plan 2–3 hours for the whole case.

What do I need to print?

The PDF has 38 pages. Print the case file single-sided, then print envelopes A, B and C without reading them and seal each one. It comes in a full colour and a printer-friendly edition.

Is the answer included?

Yes. Envelope C holds the full solution. Fill in the accusation card first, then open it.

Who is it good for?

Game night with friends, couples who like true-crime puzzles, a rainy weekend alone with coffee.

More printables

Dead Signal: printable murder mystery case file cover$9.99
West Loop, Chicago · February 2016

Dead Signal

2–3 hours37 documents41 pages3 sealed envelopes

A tech founder is found dead in her loft and it is ruled an accidental overdose. Work through phone records, building fob logs, receipts and every digital trace of her last night.

Two editions: full colour and printer-friendly
View details

One-time payment · instant download · not a subscription

The Last Encore: printable murder mystery case file cover$9.99
Frenchmen Street, New Orleans · March 1994

The Last Encore

2–3 hours36 documents40 pages3 sealed envelopes

A jazz legend is shot in the office of his own club and police blame a stranger from the alley. You get the tape of the band’s last set, the bar receipts and every statement that survives.

Two editions: full colour and printer-friendly
View details

One-time payment · instant download · not a subscription